2025 Brownlow Predictor Round 23

2025 Brownlow Predictor Round 23

With the 2025 AFL finals only weeks away, the Brownlow race is heating up.

Big bags of goals, monster disposals numbers headlined the round, with several contenders stamping their authority as we approach the finish line.

Essendon vs St Kilda

In a game that was much closer than expected, Andrew McGrath stepped up in Zach Merrett’s absence with what might have been the game of his career.  

35 disposals, 14 contested possessions, 6 clearances and 9 tackles in a gallant loss.

3. Andrew McGrath2. Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera1. Mason Redman

Fremantle vs Brisbane

In true Lions fashion, they bounced back from disappointment with a statement win.

Zac Bailey was the standout, gathering 28 disposals, booting 2 goals and winning 9 contested possessions to claim best on ground honours.

3. Zac Bailey2. Jaspa Fletcher1. 1. Hugh McCluggage

Gold Coast vs GWS

The Giants again claimed the “Expansion Cup” with their midfield stars running the show.

Finn Callaghan (29 disposals, 8 clearances, 11 contested possessions) and Tom Green (29 disposals, 19 contested possessions, 8 clearances) dominated side by side, splitting the votes between them.

3. Finn Callaghan2. Tom Green1. Noah Anderson

Carlton vs Port Adelaide

With Charlie Curnow sidelined, Harry McKay was back to his Coleman Medallist best.

He tied his career-high with 7 goals, while also collecting 21 disposals and 15 score involvements.

A dominant performance and certain three Brownlow votes.

3. Harry McKay2. George Hewett1. Patrick Cripps

Hawthorn vs Melbourne

Jack Gunston turned back the clock with a vintage performance.

The veteran forward slotted 7 goals and looked closer to his peak than retirement – an easy 3 votes.

3. Jack Gunston2. Dylan Moore1. Connor Macdonald

Adelaide vs Collingwood

In a nail-biting thriller, it was still the Brownlow favourite Nick Daicos who caught the eye.

He finished with 29 disposals, 14 contested possessions, 8 clearances and a clutch late goal to keep the Pies in it.

The umpires won’t miss him.

3. Nick Daicos2. Josh Worrell1. Jordan Dawson

North Melbourne vs Richmond

Sheezel, Sheezyball, Sheezus – whatever you want to call him, Harry Sheezel had his fingerprints all over the footy.

He tied the AFL record with 54 disposals in one of the great stat-stuffing performances of all time.

Luke Davies-Uniacke wasn’t too far behind with 40 disposals, 17 contested possessions, 10 clearances and a goal.

3. Harry Sheezel2. Luke Davies-Uniake1. Tristian Xerri

Sydney vs Geelong

Geelong continued to prove themselves the competition’s most reliable outfit, with another impressive win on the road.

Shaun Mannagh made the difference up forward, booting 3 goals from 19 touches and 9 score involvements.

Bailey Smith also kept himself firmly in the Brownlow race with 30 disposals, 14 contested possessions and over 500 metres gained.

3. Shaun Mannagh2. Bailey Smith1. Tom Stewart

Western Bulldogs vs West Coast

As expected, the Bulldogs flexed their muscle, and their captain led the way.

Marcus Bontempelli dominated with 31 disposals, 15 contested possessions, 10 clearances and 2 goals – a trademark Bont performance and a lock for the three votes.

3. Marcus Bontempelli2. Ed Richards1. Tom Liberatore


2025 AFL Brownlow Predictor Ladder: 

PlayerTeamVotes
Noah AndersonGold Coast28
Nick DaicosCollingwood28
Matt RowellGold Coast27
Tom GreenGWS26
Bailey SmithGeelong26
Caleb SerongFremantle25
Jordan DawsonAdelaide25
Max HolmesGeelong24
Hugh McCluggageBrisbane24
Zac ButtersPort Adelaide22
Ed RichardsWestern Bulldogs21
Brodie GrundySydney19
Patrick CrippsCarlton19
Wanganeen-MileraSt Kilda19
Finn CallaghanGWS G19
Andrew BrayshawFremantle18
Zach MerrettEssendon18